By: Bonnie Ronstrom
Certified Life Coach, Victim's Advocate, and Pastoral Counselor
You’ve probably read that couples counseling with a narcissist is dangerous. That’s true, but it’s only part of the picture. Even one-on-one counseling, just you and a counselor, can fall short when it treats what you’re living in as a relationship problem: a marriage problem, a family problem, two people who need to learn to get along. The advice itself is usually sound. It’s built for mutual relationships. Narcissistic abuse profoundly affects your relationships, but the core problem is that what you’ve been living in isn’t a relationship in the true sense of the word. That changes everything, including what kind of help actually helps.
When we call something a relationship, we mean something mutual. Both people see each other, consider each other, are affected by each other, and give as well as receive.
With a narcissistic person, the connection is transactional. You are related to as a tool or a resource, valued for what you provide: admiration, image, service, comfort, control. You can have known them for decades, shared children, gone to church together, been a “close” family member, and still not be in a mutual relationship.
"We call mutual connection a relationship. When only one person is truly relating, you aren't a partner. You're a resource."
— Bonnie Ronstrom, Willow Life
Why do you put gas in your car? To make it go. For whom? For you. You spend time and money on your car, and you keep giving to it over and over, not because you’re in a relationship with it. It’s a tool, and you care for it because of what it does for you.
Why do you bring a friend a get-well gift? Because you care how they feel. You want them to be well for their own sake, not because of what they do for you.
Notice the difference when each one breaks down. When your car won’t start, you probably feel frustrated, maybe angry or even afraid. It has one job, and it isn’t doing it. When a friend you meet for lunch every week says, “I don’t want to have lunch with you anymore,” you feel something else entirely: hurt, confused, sad. You miss the person, not just what they did for you.
Learning to relate mutually is a developmental task of childhood. Many narcissistic individuals are gravely underdeveloped here, so they remain stuck relating to people the way the rest of us relate to a car or a cell phone. That is the core problem.
A covert narcissist often watches and learns to layer relational, even spiritual, language on top of that transactional core. Imagine someone saying to their car, “Hey, baby, here’s some gas. I just love you so much, and this shows how much I care about you. I’ll pray you have a blessed day.” With a car, it would be obvious. When someone treats people like their car, it’s much harder to see, and it often only becomes clear through long-term patterns, not individual behaviors.
"Your effort can't build something lasting where someone didn't develop a foundation to build on." — Bonnie Ronstrom, Willow Life
Much of the help survivors receive, from counselors, pastors, books, and friends, is built on an assumption of mutuality. Even in individual sessions, you may be encouraged to:
Every one of these assumes the other person is genuinely invested in your well-being and will respond in kind. Without mutuality, you end up working harder and harder at a relationship that can’t reciprocate. When nothing changes, the conclusion is usually that you haven’t done enough, and the self-blame deepens.
Joint counseling adds another danger, giving the person who harmed you access to your healing space. The deeper issue, though, isn’t who’s in the room. It’s the framework.
When the connection isn’t mutual, nearly everything that works in healthy relationships works differently:
Boundaries are the clearest example. In a mutual relationship, a boundary is information. You tell someone what you need, and because they care about how their actions affect you, they adjust.
Without mutuality, a boundary you state becomes something else entirely: a challenge to push against, a test to see how serious you are, information about what matters to you, or an offense to punish. That’s why so many survivors say boundaries “don’t work.” They were taught a relationship tool for a situation that isn’t a mutual relationship.
Boundaries still matter, but they shift. Instead of asking the other person to respect them, they become about what you will do: the distance you keep, the access you allow, and the consequences you carry out yourself.
"In a mutual relationship, a boundary is information. Without mutuality, it becomes a target." — Bonnie Ronstrom, Willow Life
When someone faces consequences, change often appears fast: sincere-sounding apologies, a new vocabulary of growth, counseling, a spiritual awakening. The behavior may be real. Mutuality, though, isn’t a behavior. It’s a capacity, and a capacity that never developed can’t be performed into existence. It has to be built, slowly. Even in successful cases, research on narcissistic personality disorder describes change as gradual, taking 2.5 to 5 years of consistent treatment.
That’s why survivors get pulled back in, and why counselors get fooled too. Counselors often measure progress by behavior: fewer blowups, better communication, the right words in session. Someone without mutuality can learn to deliver all of it, while the survivor who stays cautious starts to look like the problem.
"When change is measured by behavior, the person doing the harm can look healthier than the person recovering from it." — Bonnie Ronstrom, Willow Life
Help that works starts from reality, not from the hope of a mutual relationship that isn’t there. That means support from someone who specializes in narcissistic abuse, clarity about what has actually been happening, strategies built for a non-mutual dynamic, and time to heal from the impacts. For more on finding that kind of help, read How to Find a Christian Counselor for Narcissistic Abuse. If your church is pressing for joint counseling, The Hidden Risks of Counseling at Your Church for Narcissistic Abuse may help.
If you’re trying to make sense of a relationship that was never truly mutual, you don’t have to sort it out alone. I provide specialized, trauma-sensitive Christian counseling for narcissistic abuse to help you gain clarity on what’s happening, navigate a non-mutual dynamic, and heal at your own pace. I work with English-speaking adults worldwide by phone or video.
Book a free consultation to explore if we are a good fit to work together.
To learn more about how I work, who I work with, what you can expect, policies and procedures, and how to choose the type of support you need, visit the Frequently Asked Questions page. For rates and booking, visit the Rates page.
Willow Life Coaching and Counseling, LLC does not provide medical care. If you are in need of care for a medical or psychiatric condition, please consult a licensed medical provider. If you are having an emergency, call 911. For a mental health crisis, call or text 988.
Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), copyright © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. Used by permission. All rights reserved. Scripture quotations marked (NLT) are taken from the Holy Bible, New Living Translation, copyright © 1996, 2004, 2015 by Tyndale House Foundation. Used by permission of Tyndale House Publishers, Carol Stream, Illinois 60188. All rights reserved. Scripture quotations taken from The Holy Bible, New International Version® NIV®. Copyright © 1973, 1978, 1984, 2011 by Biblica, Inc.™ Used by permission. All rights reserved worldwide. Scripture taken from THE MESSAGE, copyright © 1993, 2002, 2018 by Eugene H. Peterson. Used by permission of NavPress. All rights reserved. Represented by Tyndale House Publishers, Inc.