By: Bonnie Ronstrom
Certified Life Coach, Victim's Advocate, and Pastoral Counselor
Spiritual narcissists love churches. By “narcissist,” I don’t mean people who struggle with being too self-focused. That’s most of us. A narcissist is someone whose narcissism shapes every part of how they function. They’re wholly self-focused, lacking in empathy, and willing to lie, cheat, and manipulate to feed an insatiable need for power, control, and adoration.
Spiritual narcissists are predators who wear a convincing Christian costume. The Bible strongly warns about these wolves in sheep’s clothing. Often appearing to be the most devoted, gifted, and godly among us, they covertly work their destructive tentacles deep into our churches and destroy them from the inside out.
It can take years, even decades, for them to be exposed. By then, factions have formed, many people are deeply wounded, and the church is in shambles. If they’re exposed early, they simply move on to the next church, full of new beginnings and fresh prey.
As Christians, we unknowingly play a significant role in welcoming these wolves and keeping our churches an ideal place for them to thrive. We would never knowingly open the gate to a wolf. Yet we do it every week. Here are four reasons they love our churches, the church cultures that make it easy for them to stay, and what we can do to change it.
Wolves go where the sheep are. For a narcissist, a church is a feast of juicy meat, and not only because hurting people walk through its doors. The way church works makes everyone vulnerable.
Think about what we ask of every believer. Trust your leaders. Share your struggles in small group. Bring your deepest needs as prayer requests. Give your time, your money, and your loyalty. Serve without expecting anything back. Forgive quickly, overlook faults, and always give the benefit of the doubt. Submit to spiritual authority.
In healthy spaces, those are beautiful. To a narcissist, every one of them is an open door: people who hand over their trust freely, tell you exactly where they’re wounded, give generously, and have been taught that questioning a leader is a spiritual failing. That’s admiration, labor, money, and access, with a built-in reason for people not to fight back, and a good chance they won’t be believed if they do.
God saw this long ago. “Ah, shepherds of Israel who have been feeding yourselves! Should not shepherds feed the sheep? You eat the fat, you clothe yourselves with the wool, you slaughter the fat ones, but you do not feed the sheep” (Ezekiel 34:2–3).
Trust, generosity, and open hearts are gifts. Left unguarded, they’re a dinner bell.
Spiritual narcissists are incredibly hard to detect, partly because they look nothing like we expect. They can seem passionate, the “cream of the crop,” world changers, God’s answer to our prayers, deeply connected to God, charming, sincere, spiritually gifted, and discerning. As Christians, we tend to credit godliness to people who show these qualities, and in turn, we exempt them from close scrutiny.
When someone speaks our spiritual language, we often check our judgment at the door.
Giving people the benefit of the doubt looks godly, yet it’s exactly what a spiritual narcissist depends on to stay hidden. They bank on the fact that if they walk and talk like we do, we’ll assume they’re one of us. Sadly, it’s often a safe bet. The enemy’s schemes wouldn’t work if the wolves showed up obnoxious, greedy, lazy, insincere, or untalented.
“Beware of false prophets, who come to you in sheep’s clothing but inwardly are ravenous wolves. You will recognize them by their fruits” (Matthew 7:15–16).
Let people’s actions do the talking, and stay alert for the moment a spiritual narcissist accidentally reveals themselves. For more on how they hide, read Unmasking a Covert Christian Narcissist.
Narcissists live in an echo chamber. They surround themselves with a fan club of people who buy into the charade and tell them what they want to hear. Anyone who doesn’t go along gets discarded, discredited, or kept in the dark. The fan club does their bidding and defends them against any accusation. Some are new fans. Others have known the narcissist for years, even decades, and have never seen who they really are.
People start to see through the facade when they accidentally expose the narcissist’s real character, become a threat, refuse to comply, or stop being useful. The narcissist then punishes them, often in ways invisible to everyone but the victim. They may coldly discard them, or launch a covert, vicious smear campaign.
Narcissistic abusers plant seeds of doubt about their victim’s credibility long before the victim sees through the spiritual mask. They tell others the victim is a liar, crazy, or in sin. By the time the victim speaks up, listeners have already been conditioned to believe they’re lying, unstable, or influenced by evil. The smear can be so effective that anyone who tries to expose the narcissist ends up looking like the problem: divisive, gossiping, judgmental, or unforgiving. Worse, the victim’s own flaws get used as “proof.”
Then come the bystanders. Our usual response to conflict between others is “I’m not taking sides” or “I’m staying out of the drama.” When it comes to abuse, though, refusing to take a stand is siding with the abuse. Victims of covert abuse can almost never prove what’s happening to them. If we fail to protect them because we believe the narcissist’s Emmy award-winning display of spirituality, we harm them, even if we never meant to. Many victims say the wounds from a narcissist’s supporters and silent bystanders hurt as much as the abuse itself. 10 Unhelpful Christian Responses to Narcissistic Abuse explains why neutrality does so much damage.
“Without counsel plans fail, but with many advisers they succeed” (Proverbs 15:22).
There’s great wisdom in listening to the discernment of several people, as long as they aren’t united only because they belong to a narcissist’s fan club. When someone says a person isn’t who they present themselves to be, take the time and energy to discern the truth, with the humility to admit how easily we’re all deceived by master manipulators who don’t play by the rules the rest of us try to live by.
Many spiritual narcissists are skilled at spotting our insecurities and needs, then presenting themselves as exactly what we’re missing. They grow our numbers, bring innovative ideas, seem to accept us despite our flaws, or give endlessly of their time and energy. Once they fill a vital need, we easily overlook troubling behavior and convince ourselves they’re doing more good than harm.
“If anyone comes to your meeting and does not teach the truth about Christ, don’t invite that person into your house or give any kind of encouragement. Anyone who encourages such people becomes a partner in their evil work” (2 John 10–11, NLT).
“Oh, the joys of those who do not follow the advice of the wicked, or stand around with sinners, or join in with mockers” (Psalm 1:1, NLT).
We aren’t meant to stay in close community with people who habitually twist the truth, lie, and mock. Yet instead of stepping away from them, or removing them from positions of influence, we far too often stay close. Then we congratulate ourselves on not being judgmental, or on “giving grace.” Meanwhile, they keep harming us and others. How loving is that?
The Holy Spirit often warns us about people who aren’t safe. We call it a gut instinct, our radar, discernment, or just the creeps. Christians who try hard to respond in a godly way can mistake these warnings for character flaws. Without tangible evidence, we assume the reaction comes from our own tendency to be critical or unfriendly. We think, “It’s so judgmental of me to feel this way when I barely know them.” Before you talk yourself out of that warning, pray for discernment. God may be protecting you from a wolf everyone else is applauding.
Many churches are ready-made hunting grounds long before a narcissist ever walks through the door. Those habits are what let a narcissist settle in and stay. In a church with real accountability and honest communication, a narcissist is exposed quickly and moves on. Some of these patterns echo a helpful list by John of the Cross on signs of a narcissistic congregational leader.
Oversight that rubber-stamps. Boards, elders, and committees exist on paper but rarely question anything. When accountability is a formality, a narcissist faces no one who will say no.
Power held by a few. Influence gathers around one person or a small circle, sometimes official leaders, sometimes a past officer, a major donor, or someone with a devoted following. When a few people hold the real power, a narcissist only has to win over a few.
Conflict avoided at all costs. Hard conversations never happen, disagreement feels disloyal, and everyone goes along to keep the peace. A narcissist thrives where no one wants to be the one to speak up.
Secrecy and tangled communication. Decisions happen in private conversations rather than in open meetings. No one is quite sure what’s confidential and what’s public, and messages travel through third parties instead of face-to-face. That fog is the perfect cover for manipulation.
Gossip is tolerated while honest concerns get silenced. Rumors travel freely, but anyone who raises a real concern is told they’re being divisive. Narcissists often preach loudly against gossip while spreading it themselves.
No one asks why people leave. Faithful, gifted people quietly slip out the back door, and no one follows up, because everyone already suspects why. Meanwhile, new members get celebrated. A church that won’t ask hard questions about departures will never find the pattern.
Image and numbers over health. Attendance, giving, and growth matter more than whether people are actually thriving. The numbers may be closely guarded, or shared only with someone there to explain them. A narcissist who delivers growth becomes untouchable.
Discipleship that stays shallow. When people are never taught discernment, they have no way to tell spiritual performance from spiritual fruit.
None of these patterns requires a narcissist to exist. Every one of them rolls out the red carpet for one.
Spiritual narcissists love our churches because they find a whole flock taught to trust, easy cover, ready supporters, and a place where they can become needed. If we want to stop feeding them, we have to:
For church leaders and members who want to respond well, How to Support Someone Hurt by Spiritual Abuse is a good next step.
If you’re reading this because a narcissist in your church or ministry harmed you, you’re not imagining it, and you’re not the problem. It’s common to be disbelieved, sidelined, or cast as the divisive one, while the person who hurt you keeps their position and their fan club. That betrayal can shake your faith and your trust in every church leader you meet.
You don’t have to sort it out alone. Church Hurt vs. Spiritual Abuse can help you name what happened, and The Hidden Risks of Counseling at Your Church for Narcissistic Abuse explains why independent support matters. I provide trauma-sensitive Christian counseling for spiritual abuse to help you gain clarity, navigate what’s happening, and heal at your own pace.
Book a free consultation to explore if we are a good fit to work together.
To learn more about how I work, who I work with, what you can expect, policies and procedures, and how to choose the type of support you need, visit the Frequently Asked Questions page. For rates and booking, visit the Rates page.
Willow Life Coaching and Counseling, LLC does not provide medical care. If you are in need of care for a medical or psychiatric condition, please consult a licensed medical provider. If you are having an emergency, call 911. For a mental health crisis, call or text 988.
Scripture quotations are from the ESV® Bible (The Holy Bible, English Standard Version®), copyright © 2001 by Crossway, a publishing ministry of Good News Publishers. Used by permission. All rights reserved. Scripture quotations marked (NLT) are taken from the Holy Bible, New Living Translation, copyright © 1996, 2004, 2015 by Tyndale House Foundation. Used by permission of Tyndale House Publishers, Carol Stream, Illinois 60188. All rights reserved. Scripture quotations taken from The Holy Bible, New International Version® NIV®. Copyright © 1973, 1978, 1984, 2011 by Biblica, Inc.™ Used by permission. All rights reserved worldwide. Scripture taken from THE MESSAGE, copyright © 1993, 2002, 2018 by Eugene H. Peterson. Used by permission of NavPress. All rights reserved. Represented by Tyndale House Publishers, Inc.